Politicians Are Disposable, Stop Treating Them Otherwise
NOVEMBER 21st, 2026 | RYAN TYLER
Politicians Are Disposable, Stop Treating Them Otherwise
NOVEMBER 21st, 2026 | RYAN TYLER
There's something deeply wrong with the way people treat politicians. Somewhere along the way, we stopped treating them like employees and started treating them like religious figures. We defend them, worship them, make excuses for them, and build entire political identities around their personalities. We convince ourselves they're playing 4D chess when they're actually playing checkers. We convince ourselves that they're irreplaceable, that nobody else could possibly do what they do, and that abandoning them would somehow mean abandoning everything we believe in.
That's ridiculous.
Pierre Poilievre is not a superhero. Donald Trump is not a god. Danielle Smith is not the saviour of Alberta, and Stephen Harper is not some untouchable political genius whose ideas should be preserved for another hundred years. They're politicians. They are temporary occupants of positions of power, and their usefulness has an expiration.
This is something conservatives, in particular, desperately need to understand.
Politicians are disposable. Their ideas are disposable. Their political movements are disposable. The moment they stop serving the interests of the people who elected them, they should be replaced. No tears, no endless excuses, and no loyalty.
The funny thing is, people understand this idea in practically every other area of life. If your employee stops doing their job, you replace them. If your business strategy stops working, you change it. If your car stops running, you fix it or get another one. You probably replace your smartphone every three years.
Look at Pierre Poilievre. For years, conservatives treated him like the inevitable next prime minister. He was going to destroy the Liberals, restore Canada, fix the economy, and usher in some sort of conservative renaissance. His supporters weren't merely enthusiastic, they were convinced he was the only man in the country capable of doing the job.
Then came the 2025 election.
Poilievre lost. The Conservatives failed to form government, and he even lost his own seat before returning to Parliament through a byelection. Suddenly, the man who had been treated like an unstoppable political force had become an afterthought in the era of Trump.
There's nothing wrong with giving Poilievre another chance. Perhaps he'll learn from the last election, adapt his approach, broaden his appeal, or become a more effective leader. Perhaps he won't. That's exactly the point. His future should depend on whether he can deliver, not on whether his supporters have developed an emotional attachment to him.
If Poilievre can't win, replace him. If his ideas aren't working, abandon them. If the Conservatives need a different direction, find one. It isn't complicated. Sometimes "muh principles" need to be re-evaluated to avoid cyclical defeat.
And before you all start explaining that replacing him would be like surrendering to the Liberals, understand this: the Conservative Party exists to win elections and advance conservative principles. It does not exist to give Pierre Poilievre a lifelong career in the House Of Commons.
The same principle applies to Donald Trump.
Trump has accomplished things that many conservatives spent decades trying to do. He challenged established political institutions, smashed biased journalists, confronted sections of the American bureaucracy, exposed flaws in the system, and forced conversations about immigration, trade, energy, national sovereignty, and the direction of Western politics. His political instincts have been extraordinary at times. His ability to connect with a particular segment of the electorate is something his opponents have repeatedly underestimated.
So what?
I was a Trump supporter in 2016 and 2024, but let's be honest: it's all getting exhausting. The tariff bullshit, the economic volatility, the war in Iran. I don't know about you, but I'm over it. I was mildly relieved to see MAGA get their asses handed to them in the mid-terms.
Trump is a politician, not a religion. His supporters need to stop treating every criticism of him as an attack on the entire conservative movement. Sometimes he's right, sometimes he is wrong. Sometimes his decisions are strategically brilliant, and sometimes they are spectacularly stupid. There is no reason to pretend otherwise.
The United States is not Donald Trump. The Republican Party is not Donald Trump. Conservatism isn't Donald Trump.
There's also a practical consideration here.Trump cannot remain president forever. The American Constitution limits presidents to two elected terms, and whatever happens politically, the Republican Party will eventually have to find a future beyond him. If they fail to dig themselves out of a hole with real changes, they'll hand Democrats eternal power.
That would be pathetic.
The entire point of political movements should be to build something that survives the people who lead them. They should evolve and be adaptable. If everything collapses the moment one politician leaves office, then the movement was never worth a turd to begin with.
Now, let's talk about Danielle Smith.
Alberta conservatives have developed their own peculiar relationship with political personalities. Smith has become a central figure in a province where many voters have spent years feeling ignored by Ottawa, frustrated by federal energy policy, and increasingly disconnected from the political direction of the country. She has given those people a political voice, and she has been willing to confront issues that previous premiers preferred to avoid.
That deserves recognition, but it doesn't make her indispensable.
The separatist question is a perfect example. Smith finally allowed Albertans to have a democratic discussion about their relationship with Confederation. It was a discussion that needed to happen, regardless of how people felt about the outcome. The referendum ultimately rejected the separation proposition, and Smith accepted the result. Now she has to deal with the political consequences of having opened a debate that some people wanted to continue and others wanted buried.
That's politics. There is no lifetime guarantee attached to being premier.
Smith's supporters need to understand that the UCP is not the Danielle Smith. It is a political party, and its purpose is to govern Alberta. If Smith can deliver, maintain public support, and lead the party to another victory, then she deserves the opportunity to continue. If she can't, the party needs to move on. But they should figure it out before the next election, or risk an NDP victory.
The same applies to the separatists who believe that removing Smith is somehow going to bring Alberta closer to independence. If her departure simply hands the province to the NDP, what exactly have they accomplished? Political movements need to understand consequences, not just emotions. And sometimes the person you dislike is still preferable to the alternative.
But even that doesn't mean Smith should be protected indefinitely.
If another conservative leader can do a better job, find that person. If the UCP needs to change its approach, change it. Alberta is not going to disappear because Danielle Smith retires from politics. The province existed before her, and it will exist long after her.
Then there's Stephen Harper. I'm tired of hearing about this guy. He's old news. You all need to stop using him as a benchmark for what conservatism should be.
There's a legitimate argument that he was one of the most consequential conservative politicians in modern Canadian history. He united a broken right, built a national political coalition, won three consecutive elections, and governed Canada for nearly a decade. His government made significant changes to taxation, criminal justice, resource development, and the direction of federal politics. Conservatives have plenty of reasons to appreciate what he accomplished.
But he left crucial senate seats vacant, failed to seriously change Canada's trajectory, and left most of our liberal institutions untouched.
At what point do we stop treating his political legacy as a blueprint for every future Conservative leader? At what point do we accept that the country has changed, the electorate has changed, the political environment has changed, and some of the strategies that worked twenty years ago might not work today?
Harper was successful in his time. That doesn't mean every idea he had should be preserved indefinitely. It certainly doesn't mean Poilievre should spend his political career trying to recreate the Harper years. A modern Conservative Party needs to be capable of developing its own ideas, building its own coalition, and adapting to the country as it actually exists.
Nostalgia is not a political strategy.
Harper himself should be perfectly capable of understanding that. He built a political movement by recognizing that the old arrangement on the Canadian right wasn't working. He didn't spend his entire career insisting that the Progressive Conservatives and Reform Party should remain divided. He recognized that something needed to change.
That's the lesson.
The Cultural Problem
There is a much bigger problem here, and it extends well beyond these four politicians. We've created a political culture in which people become so emotionally invested in individual personalities that they lose sight of the actual objectives. They start defending politicians instead of evaluating them. They become more interested in protecting reputations than achieving results.
This is how political movements become stagnant.
A politician makes a mistake, and his supporters invent an excuse. He loses an election, and they blame everyone except him. He abandons a promise, and suddenly that promise was never important anyway. He fails to deliver, and his supporters tell everyone to be patient because the next election will be different. Like, maybe this time he'll pay you $5000.
How many times are we supposed to repeat this?
There's nothing inherently disloyal about replacing a political leader. In fact, sometimes it is the most responsible thing a political party can do. Loyalty to a political objective should always take precedence over loyalty to the person temporarily tasked with achieving it.
The left understands this in its own way. Political parties reinvent themselves, abandon unpopular leaders, change their messaging, and find new personalities when the circumstances demand it. Look at Mark Carney. Conservatives should be equally capable of doing so without having an existential crisis every time somebody suggests their favourite politician might not be the answer.
And this brings us to the most important distinction of all. There is a difference between respecting somebody's accomplishments and worshipping them. There's a difference between supporting a politician and surrendering your ability to think critically about them. There's a difference between believing in a political movement and believing that one particular person must lead it forever.
We need to stop confusing the two.
Pierre Poilievre might become prime minister one day. He might not. Donald Trump might leave behind a Republican Party that's stronger, or he might leave it struggling to find its identity. Danielle Smith might lead the UCP to another victory, or Alberta might decide it's time for somebody else.
Politicians are temporary flashes in the pan. Political parties should be just as temporary. Political principles can evolve. Leaders come and go, and sometimes the best thing they can do for the movement they represent is get out of the way.
Stop treating politicians like gods. Stop making excuses for people who are supposed to be working for you. Stop confusing a man's popularity with his competence, his political instincts with his judgment, or his past accomplishments with some sort of permanent entitlement.
You hired them. You can fire them.
If your entire political philosophy falls apart because one politician retires, loses an election, or turns out to be less impressive than you imagined, maybe the problem was never the politician in the first place.